Focused on providing independent journalism.

Thursday, 26 February 2015

Court rules cop who was fired for blowing the whistle on NYPD arrest quotas can sue


© Flickr/ Ethan



A federal appeals court ruled in favor of a New York City police officer who alleges he was unjustly punished by his superiors after he exposed an illegal quota system within his Bronx precinct.

In a ruling Thursday, the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan overturned a lower court's decision to dismiss the suit, brought by Officer Craig Matthews and the New York Civil Liberties Union in 2012.


"Quotas lead to illegal arrests, criminal summonses and ruined lives. They undermine the trust between the police and the people they are supposed to be protecting and serving," said NYCLU Associate Legal Director Christopher Dunn, lead counsel in the case.


"Today's decision protects the ability of police officers to speak out against this kind of misconduct when they see it. New York City's finest should be applauded when they expose abuse, not abused and retaliated against."


The city Law Department says it's reviewing the decision, while the NYPD still maintains it does not operate under arrest or summons quotas.


Matthews, a 17-year veteran of the NYPD, said supervisors at the 42nd Precinct in the Bronx kept color-coded records of which officers met quota, and punished those who fell short.


Since Matthews objected to the system, he has been subject to a wide range of retaliation, including punitive assignments, overtime and leave denial, separation from his longtime partner, poor evaluations and constant harassment and threats, according to the lawsuit.


Last year, a federal judge with the Southern District of New York ruled that Matthews' lawsuit could not proceed because the officer was speaking as a public employee and not as a citizen.


The First Amendment notoriously does not protect the speech of public employees.


Thursday's decision states that Matthews was acting as a citizen and not as a public employee when he told his supervisors about the quotas. The ruling allows Matthews' civil rights suit to move forward.


"Officer Matthews has followed the oath he made to uphold the Constitution and his community," said NYCLU Executive Director Donna Lieberman. "Instead of retaliating against officers who expose unjust and illegal practices, the NYPD should work to ensure that nobody is arrested because of arbitrary and illegal quotas."


The Patrolmen's Benevolent Association, the largest NYPD union and generally one of the NYCLU's fiercest critics, told BuzzFeed News that it supports the decision.


"This union has been warning about the dangers of police quotas for over a decade," said PBA President Pat Lynch. "This decision comes at an important time because despite management's claim that they want quality not quantity, illegal quotas for police activities are, unfortunately, alive and well in the NYPD."


Paris throws temper tantrum after French lawmakers hold 'unauthorized' meetings with Assad, Hezbollah


© Reuters/SANA

French President Francois Hollande (Reuters/Vincent Kessler) and Syria's President Bashar al-Assad.



Four French lawmakers have been slammed by their government and one of them threatened with sanctions and suspension after an unauthorized meeting with Syrian President Bashar Assad in Damascus as well with a Hezbollah member.

The group of four cross-party lawmakers, identified as Gerard Bapt, Jean-Pierre Vial, Jacques Myard and Francois Zochetto, went to the Middle East on a ''personal mission to see what is going on, to hear, listen."


According to the Syrian state news agency, Assad and the French lawmakers discussed developments and challenges facing Arab and European nations, especially those pertaining to terrorism.


"We met Bashar al-Assad for a good hour. It went very well," Jacques Myard, an MP from the opposition UMP party, told but refused to give details.


The lawmakers also met with Hezbollah's international relations officer, Ammar Musawi, in Beirut on Wednesday.


According to the statement, Musawi called on countries to combat terrorism and fight against extremist groups and also to stop helping fundamentalist groups. The visit, which was not authorized by the French government , triggered harsh condemnation.


"I fully condemn [this visit]. Assad is not an authoritarian dictator, he is a butcher," Socialist Party Chairman Jean-Christophe Cambadelis has told RTL radio as quoted by Reuters. "I have written to Gerard Bapt, I will summon him and take sanctions."


Bapt as well as Vial are presidents of the France-Syria Friendship Group in the French parliament.


It has, however, been reported that Bapt was not present at the meeting with President Assad. Reuters says Bapt personally confirmed that in a text message to the news agency.


President Francois Hollande slammed French lawmakers for meeting with Syrian President Bashar Assad, whom he branded a "dictator."


"I condemn this initiative. I condemn it because French lawmakers have taken it upon themselves to meet with a dictator who is the cause of one of the worst civil wars of recent years," Hollande told reporters on an official trip to the Philippines.


Hollande has also said he supported and encouraged sanctions against all four members of the delegation.


Prime Minister Manuel Valls said the visit was "a moral failing" and compared Assad to a butcher, hinting at atrocities committed by governmental troops.


France cut diplomatic ties with Syria in 2012 and now supports the Syrian opposition, seeking the removal of Assad from power.


However, recent reports suggest more countries and politicians are considering re-engagement with Assad's regime.


Thus, according to Reuters, numerous European countries, including Austria, Bulgaria, Denmark, Romania and Spain are now leaning toward rapprochement with Syria.


The report suggested that even in those EU countries that are officially opposed to renewed relations, there is talk that the Syrian crisis could have been handled better. One senior French diplomat admitted that closing the embassy was a mistake, the news agency said.


The gradual change in attitude toward Syria, the news agency noted, has gained pace since Islamic State (also known as ISIS or ISIL) made territorial gains in Syria and Iraq, prompting US-led aerial attacks on ISIS positions in the country - despite harsh criticism from Damascus, which accused Washington of violating its territorial integrity.


Detainees who were tortured at Chicago's Homan Square "black site" speak out


© Scott Olson/Getty



On Tuesday, s Spencer Ackerman reported on the "equivalent of a CIA black site" operated by police in Chicago. When computer program analyst Kory Wright opened the story, he told me, "I immediately recognized the building" — because, the Chicago resident says, he was zip-tied to a bench there for hours in an intentionally overheated room without access to water or a bathroom, eventually giving false statements to try and end his ordeal.

A friend of Wright's swept up in the same police raid described his own brutal treatment at the facility, known as Homan Square, including attacks to his face and genitals. The experiences of the two men line up with the way defense attorneys described the "black site" warehouse to Ackerman: as a place where detainees were held off the books, without access to lawyers, while being beaten or shackled for long periods of time.


Wright claims that nine years ago, he spent "at least six [brutal] hours" at the Homan facility on his 21st birthday. He says that he was never read his Miranda rights, and that his arrest was not put into the police system until after his ordeal was over. Wright was reminded of the facility again this week when he noticed a tweet from a writer he admires, Ta-Nehisi Coates, linking to Ackerman's story. Ackerman compared Homan Square to the network of shadowy torture centers built by the CIA across the Middle East — but focused "on Americans, most often poor, black and brown," rather than on purported overseas terrorists.


Also unlike CIA black sites, Homan Square wasn't a completely furtive enterprise. Several lawyers and anti-police brutality advocates with whom I spoke knew that suspects were routinely detained at Homan. The facility houses many of the police department's special units, including the anti-gang and anti-drug task forces, along with the evidence-retrieval unit. Once suspects arrived at Homan, they did not have to be booked immediately, at least not as far as the police department was concerned, according to the people with whom I spoke. In fact, it was possible that a suspect's arrest report wouldn't show that he or she had ever been to Homan. Further, police could detain individuals at Homan for hours, or disappear them, before shipping them off to a district station for processing.


The Chicago Police Department declined to address the specific allegations from Wright and his friend, providing only a general statement denying abuses at Homan Square. (The same statement also appears in Ackerman's story.) "CPD abides by all laws, rules and guidelines pertaining to any interviews of suspects or witnesses, at Homan Square or any other CPD facility," the statement read. "There are always records of anyone who is arrested by CPD, and this is not any different at Homan Square."


Kory Wright disagrees.





Kory Wright about one month before his detention at Homan Square.



It was late on the hot morning of June 29, 2006 — Kory Wright's 21st birthday — when he set out for the North Lawndale residence of a relative, a short walk from his own. "I know they got a lot of connections over there, and he said I can get my hair braided, so I came over and I was getting my hair braided," Wright says. He says this relative sold crack cocaine, and that his mother had warned him prior to June 29 to keep his distance, but "you know, they good people."

As Wright was having his hair braided on the porch, "a nice clean lady comes and asks to buy some drugs." According to Wright, the woman "had a fifty [dollar bill]. And I exchanged the fifty. I gave her the change and then she completed her transaction with my [relative]."


Wright claims the drug-buyer was an undercover cop, and that the entire transaction was recorded by Chicago police, because two or three minutes after the drug deal, officers in plain clothes swarmed the house and detained Wright, two of his relatives, and one of his friends, Deandre Hutcherson. "They searched us first and then they took us all down to that one place I'm talking about," Wright says, referring to the Homan interrogation site. Wright and Hutcherson both insist the police never read them their Miranda rights.


"When we first got to that place, we went in a garage and they walked us up the stairs," he says. Phone calls to counsel and family were denied, Wright and Hutcherson say, while no fingerprints were taken, and no paperwork was filled out — which means there was no evidence they were ever there. "I tried to tell them it was my birthday," he says, "and I think I was in the wrong place at the wrong time. He [a Chicago police officer] got the nerve to go get his friend, and they, like, sung happy birthday." Wright believes the virulent police officers were taunting him. "I see it [Homan] everyday. I shudder," says Wright, whose neighborhood was just south of the facility.


The four men were split up and placed in small, separate rooms that were the size of office cubicles. It was a steamy summer day, and Wright was sweating profusely at Homan; he believes the police either turned the heat on, or turned the air conditioning off, to sweat him out. "When we first got in there it was room-temperature, and before he [a Chicago police officer] left, he was like, 'It's gon' get a little hot in here,'" says Hutcherson, now 29.


For six hours, a sweaty Wright sat zip-tied to a bench with no access to a restroom, a telephone or water. "They strapped me — like across, kind of — to a bench, and my hands were strapped on both sides of me," he says. "I can't even scratch my face." When Wright first arrived at Homan, he was left alone for a while in the hot room. Wright asked the police if he could call his mother, but instead, various police officers came "in and out. They were badgering me with questions. 'Tell me about this murder!'" one officer shouted. Wright provided his interrogator with false information and names, with the hope of making it stop. He told me he was "trying to get out of the situation and give them something they wanted."


Meanwhile, Hutcherson — also shackled to a bench — was being interrogated in another room. "He [a Chicago police officer] gets up, walking toward me," Hutcherson alleges. "I already know what's finna happen. I brace myself, and he hit me a little bit and then take his foot and stepped on my groin." According to Hutcherson, the officer struck him two or three times in the face before kicking his penis.


"You must think I'm a fucking idiot," Hutcherson says his attacker told him. Within an hour, Hutcherson, who was in town for his mother's funeral, faked an asthma attack that unnerved the police. He says they then released him from detention and sent him on his way.


The descriptions that Wright and Hutcherson provided of their experiences at Homan are eerily similar to how Tracy Siska, executive director of the Chicago Justice Project, described such torture in :



Isolation, deprivation of food, other outside contact. It's meant to be a lot of touchless torture. So they're not touching you, which in the human-rights field is more powerful and scary because it doesn't leave marks but leaves huge internal wounds.



Siska has known about the goings-on at Homan "since about the mid- to late-2000s." Siska also said that most of those detained at Homan are poor, black and brown people suspected of street crimes. When I asked why reporters haven't covered the abuses allegedly occurring there, Siska replied with a slight chuckle, "That's the million dollar question. The problem is a lot of reporters agree with the police perspective."

More broadly, Wright's tale is typical of low-income, minoritized people victimized by America's criminal justice system. Eventually, he was taken to Cook County jail, where he was processed and charged with distribution of heroin and cocaine. Given his low-income status, Wright's only option for counsel was a public defender.


Wright's lawyer, he says, was pregnant and overworked, while Wright suffered through multiple continuances. When his public defender gave birth, Wright was assigned a new attorney, who also, naturally, had a taxing caseload. In the end, the drug charges against Wright were thrown out, though not before he'd spent six months under house arrest because his mother lacked the money to fund a bond for release.


Kory Wright was attending Wilbur Wright Community College, and taking criminal justice courses, when he was detained at Homan. He says he had hopes of becoming a police officer in the city of Chicago before that June day. Wright told me a story about how police — when he was 16 years old — had roughed up him up, along with some friends of his. Afterwards, Wright decided he wanted to be a counterweight to that sort of police-initiated harassment, which regularly afflicts communities such as North Lawndale. But his experience at Homan, and his subsequent arrest, caused him to miss a semester of school.


Fortunately, Wright recovered, and today, at age 29, he is working on his master's degree in network engineering at DePaul University. He lives in Bronzeville, a neighborhood on Chicago's South Side, and is the father of a new baby girl. But the touchless torture he says he suffered at Homan continues to haunt him. "The whole thing caused a rift between me and my mom. I didn't like being black at all after that, and when I got to DePaul, I started trying to be as white as possible," a doleful Wright told me. "Being black is a curse."


Our model of the world gives us the capacity for wonder

childhood



The awe and wonder of childhood



My son recently asked me if it was possible that we lived on a speck of dust in a much larger universe. He explained that he had just watched again and it had him thinking. I, ever eager to promote the impossible, said I don't see why not. And he walked about blissfully conjuring the possibilities.

What is it about fantastic speculation that makes it so compelling a past time? Many of us read science fiction, or watch documentaries about aspects of our world that we will never experience, and yet we love it. We love to hear that there may be parallel universes or ways to go back in time. I recently read an article (link is external) in magazine that argued that we may live in the center of a black hole, created in a multiverse, where black holes that experience just the right conditions expand into universes like our own—as if they were flowers. I felt like I had taken mescal after reading that article. I walked around for a week just smiling at everything.


But why?


To my knowledge, no other species cares if we live inside or outside of a blackhole. No other species considers it interesting that quantum probability requires something to collapse the wave function (like consciousness) or else that there are many worlds, infinite and ever increasing parallel universes in which every possibility happens. All of these theories are like drugs—like mind-expanding mushrooms that open Huxley's doors of perception. They each carry with them such a fantastic vision of reality that we are forced to rethink our place in the universe and thereby the limits of who we are as individuals, as a species, and as life itself.


What is it that makes this capacity for wonder possible?


The answer lies in part in how we understand ourselves.


Let me explain.


Episodic future thinking


Since about the mid-1990s researchers began to identify cells in the hippocampus that were active when animals 'thought about' places they were about to visit. In some of the initial studies, rats were found to reactivate sequences of place cells in their hippocampus during sleep that were also actived together when the animals were awake. This animal dreaming has since been found to occur when animals need to make a difficult decision about where to go next. In these case, the animals reactivate past memories such they can search their memory for the best way forward. This is called episodic future thinking and it is deeply related to our ability to deliberate about the future (see Pezzulo et al., 2014).


Even more interesting is the observation that animals can activate new sequences in their minds that are plausible, but have nonetheless never been experienced. Now the animal isn't just remembering, it is creating a model of its world. Within that model, the animal can conjure up a future that is custom built to its own specifications. This self-projection has often been speculated to be the domain of humans alone, but we now know it isn't so.


Hugging your virtual mom


Buildig a model of the world in our heads allows us to simulate reality. This idea is supported by the cognition. Hesslow (2002) has done a lot of work outlining this theory, but the basic idea is fairly simple. If the mind can use its own output as new input, then it can simulate reality. We can imagine that we are going on vacation, getting hit by a bus, or falling in love. When we do this, areas in our brain are activated that are associated with our actual experience of realities similar to the one we envision—both in sensory and motor areas—and their probable outcomes are activated as well. If we imagine playing the piano, our brain wiggles our cognitive fingers. If we imagine flying to the moon, our brain looks out the window at the shrinking blue earth in our minds. Just imagine giving your mom a hug, and immediately consequences begin to proliferate in your mind. Your brain is hugging your virtual mom, who is in turn virtually hugging you back.


We are our model of the world


Now what's quite important here is something you may have missed. If the animal is building a model of its world, then it is also building a model of itself. That is, to the extent that we think we are anything, we must do so in relation to what we understand about the place, the world, the universe in which we live. As our understanding of that place changes, we change as well.


Indeed, arguably one of the most significant contributions of psychology is that our understanding of ourselves is more defined by what we believe in our heads than by the actual external world that we experience. If you imagine you are the center of the universe, then you experience yourself as a different person than one who imagines they live on a speck of dust. However, even better, if you can imagine living in different kinds of universes, then who you are becomes a fantastic landscape of possibilities.


The wonder of science and art lies in their capacity to alter our model of the world, and thereby alter our conception of ourselves.


When I read today in Quanta Magazine (link is external) that physicists at University College London were looking for evidence of other universes by looking for dents in ours, detectable by concentric rings in the cosmic background radiation of our universe, I swooned. In that moment, my brain simulated something like a child blowing bubbles, and our universe, somehow being one among many, in a vast inflationary process that breathes out worlds in countless varieties, each with various versions of things like me. And then my mind just popped.


Snake makes a rare winter appearance in Stephenville, Maryland


© Jake Claypoole

A Snake in Winter



Jake Claypoole of Stevenville spotted something unusual when he took his son sledding near the park and ride across from Kent Landing Shopping Center, commonly called Kmart hill, about noon Wednesday, Feb. 18. He noticed a 3-foot snake on top of the ice on the storm water management pond.

Claypoole said he thought the snake was dead at first, but then he noticed its tongue moving and it began slithering toward the snow.

He said he watched and took pictures for about 20 minutes as the snake made its way off the ice, across the snow and into some nearby brush.


He said he had never seen a snake out in the winter on snow or ice before.


[embedded content]




Bill Killen of the Wye Research and Education Center at the University of Maryland Extension in Queenstown identified the snake as a garter snake from the photos on Monday, Feb. 23.

While snakes may sometimes come out in the winter to sun themselves on a warm day, Killen agreed it was unusual for the snake to come out during the frigid arctic temperatures the area experienced last week.


"It's not very often that they do that," he said.


Killen speculated the snake may have been hibernating under the parking lot. Unless it was able to find its way under cover, it likely became lunch for a bird.


Shame: Florida teacher posts 'student terror list'

terrorist wheel of fortune

© Anthony Freda Art



Last week, a St. Pete high school teacher was stuck in hot water over shaming students by placing their names on a "student terrorist list" and posting it on the door. It is unclear what was the motive for his actions. The teacher, however, went so far as to give the blacklisted students Arabic sounding alias names.

While the teacher sounds like he might have a screw loose - is he in reality doing what he was trained to do?


In other words, was he doing "his job" but just went one tad too far? See below for more. Notably, it doesn't appear that he will be reprimanded for his actions.


While this particular story is of a quirky, zany nature, the truth is, that government schools are bent toward detecting future thought-crime terrorism in students.


[embedded content]




Here are three examples of trying to root out "terrorism" in students:

The Eagle Forum List of Nosy Questions for Students - Submitted by Parents. Follow-up info.


IS YOUR CHILD A TERRORIST? U.S. GOVERNMENT QUESTIONNAIRE RATES FAMILIES AT RISK FOR EXTREMISM

Parents Outraged by "Challenge" Program that Had Students Bear Their Souls Without Permission


A reader tells us that in middle school, during the mid-1990s, a work book was passed around for the students to fill out in Health Class/Study Hall. They were to answer extremely private questions - similar to the ones in the "Nosy questions" and "Challenge" program above. The books were kept on the last day of school. When the student inquired about them, s/he was told they were being sent to a company but was not told why.


Perhaps the teacher above took the cue just that much too far - and accidentally spilled the beans with his twisted form of punishment.


King crab from Arctic waters found on Redcar beach, UK




King Crab on Redcar beach





He's spent his working life beneath the sea but even oceanographer David McCreadie was baffled by a rare visitor to Redcar.


For the formidable-looking red crustacean found by David's fiancee Diane Weinoski looks for all the world like a king crab - and they hardly ever stray from considerably icier waters.


Members of the lithododid family, king crabs are large, tasty and usually found in seas MUCH colder than Redcar's.


And despite having worked and played in oceans across the world since the mid-1960s, David has never heard of one being found this far south.





Oceanographer David McCreadie



His suspicion that the six-legged visitor was a king crab species has now been confirmed by David's friend and world crab expert Dr Norman Sloan, of the remote Queen Charlotte Islands in British Columbia, Canada. Dr Sloan, who used to work in the Natural History Museum, is now contacting an expert on British crustaceans to discuss it further.

David, 66, who was brought up in Redcar but now lives in Great Ayton, said: "I have dived as an amateur and professional since 1966 and never seen one anywhere near here before.


"I have heard that king crabs have migrated under the Arctic ice cap and been found in Norway, but this is so far south."


In a lifetime devoted to marine matters, after studying oceanography and marine biology in Bangor, North Wales, in 1966, David stayed to do research before starting a successful oyster hatchery, mussel business and lobster tanks.


Since then, he's started a smokery which supplies the Royal Family, worked as a senior offshore inspection rep in Abu Dhabi and is currently senior lecturer at the TWI Techonology Centre on Riverside Park, Middlesbrough.


In other words, when it comes to life under the sea, he knows what he's talking about.


David, a former pupil of Sir William Turner's School in Redcar, said: "I know my crustaceans and when I saw this one, I knew it was special.


"I know king crabs are common in the Arctic, especially around Alaska, and they have turned up in Norway recently, but how on earth this one has got so far south, I have no idea. To my knowledge, this is the first one.


"It could only come from very cold, deep water but we don't have very cold deep water in the North Sea.


"Perhaps it was on its summer holidays!"


Sadly, the king crab's Redcar vacation didn't last long.


It was alive when Diane first came across it last Friday, but a subsequent return to the beach found it dead on the sands.